\n
Autorzy: Y. Carmon i A. Savyon*
\n
21 pa\u017adziernika 2015 r. ira\u0144ski Najwy\u017cszy Przyw\u00f3dca, Ali Chamenei, opublikowa\u0142 list z wytycznymi do ira\u0144skiego prezydenta, Hassana Rohaniego, o realizacji Wsp\u00f3lnego Kompleksowego Planu Dzia\u0142ania (JCPOA). Publikacja listu zbiega si\u0119 z dniami Aszura, kt\u00f3re maj\u0105 w Iranie \u017cywotne znaczenie religijne i narodowe i symbolizuj\u0105 niez\u0142omno\u015b\u0107 wobec si\u0142 z\u0142a. List ten, zamierzony jako dokument historyczny, zapewniaj\u0105cy przysz\u0142o\u015b\u0107 Iranu, zosta\u0142 zamieszczony na witrynie internetowej Chameneiego po persku i tweetowany z jego konta Twittera oraz zamieszczony po angielsku na stronie Facebooka (patrz Aneksy<\/B>) i opublikowany po angielsku przez oficjalny Urz\u0105d Radiofoniczny Republiki Islamskiej IRIB (patrz poni\u017cej). List jest teraz podstawowym dokumentem we wszystkich sprawach dotycz\u0105cych JCPOA i przedstawia warunki, pod jakimi Iran b\u0119dzie sk\u0142onny go realizowa\u0107.
\n
List, zdefiniowany przez Chameneiego na jego witrynie jako \u201cwarunkowa aprobata\u201d JCPOA, wysuwa szereg nowych warunk\u00f3w dla wykonania porozumienia przez Iran. Te warunki stanowi\u0105 sp\u00f3\u017anione i jednostronne dodatki do porozumienia zako\u0144czonego trzy miesi\u0105ce wcze\u015bniej i fundamentalnie je zmieniaj\u0105. Chamenei podkre\u015bla, \u017ce porozumienie oczekuje na jego opini\u0119 po tym, co nazwa\u0142 \u201cdok\u0142adn\u0105 i od odpowiedzialn\u0105 analiz\u0105\u201d w Mad\u017clisie i \u201czezwoleniu na to porozumienie przez kana\u0142y prawnicze\u201d w Najwy\u017cszej Radzie Bezpiecze\u0144stwa Narodowego Iranu.
\n
![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25366.jpg\")
\n
\n
Nale\u017cy ponadto zaznaczy\u0107, \u017ce we wprowadzeniu do nowych warunk\u00f3w Chamenei atakuje z wielk\u0105 wrogo\u015bci\u0105 USA i prezydenta Obam\u0119, i wzywa do \u015bcigania s\u0105downego Obamy przez mi\u0119dzynarodowe instytucje prawne. Oznajmia, \u017ce Obama wys\u0142a\u0142 mu dwa listy deklaruj\u0105ce, \u017ce nie ma \u017cadnych zamiar\u00f3w obalania re\u017cimu Republiki Islamskiej Iranu, ale dodaje, \u017ce poparcie USA dla fitna<\/I> w Iranie (tj. zamieszkach po wyborach 2009 r.), ich pomoc finansowa dla przeciwnik\u00f3w Republiki i ich jawne gro\u017aby zaatakowania Iranu dowiod\u0142y czego\u015b odwrotnego i ujawni\u0142y prawdziwe zamiary przyw\u00f3dc\u00f3w Ameryki, kt\u00f3rych wrogo\u015b\u0107 wobec Iranu nie sko\u0144czy si\u0119. Napisa\u0142, \u017ce zachowanie Amerykan\u00f3w podczas rozm\u00f3w nuklearnych jest kolejnym ogniwem w \u0142a\u0144cuchu ich wrogo\u015bci wobec Iranu, \u017ce Ameryka przyst\u0105pi\u0142a do tych rozm\u00f3w z zamiarem \u201eoszustwa\u201d i \u017ce dlatego Iran musi pozosta\u0107 czujny w \u015bwietle wrogich zamiar\u00f3w Ameryki.
\n
Zestaw warunk\u00f3w przedstawionych przez Chameneiego tworzy sytuacj\u0119, w kt\u00f3rej strona ira\u0144ska nie tylko powstrzymuje si\u0119 od zaaprobowania JCPOA<\/A> [1]<\/A>, ale w ka\u017cdym niemal punkcie tworzy osobne przeszkody, tak \u017ce realizacja porozumienia nie jest mo\u017cliwa. Poni\u017cej podajemy dziewi\u0119\u0107 warunk\u00f3w Chameneiego i ich implikacje: Warunki Chameneiego dla realizowania przez Iran JCPOA<\/B> Warunek pierwszy:<\/B> Chamenei \u017c\u0105da, by USA i Europa znios\u0142y sankcje, nie za\u015b zawiesi\u0142y je, i dodatkowo domaga si\u0119 \u201csolidnych i wystarczaj\u0105cych\u201d gwarancji z g\u00f3ry, \u017ce zostanie to zrobione zanim Iran podejmie kroki i spe\u0142ni swoje zobowi\u0105zania zgodnie z porozumieniem. Te gwarancje, nalega Chamenei, musz\u0105 obejmowa\u0107 mi\u0119dzy innymi oficjalny list od prezydenta USA i od UE, zobowi\u0105zuj\u0105cy si\u0119 do pe\u0142nego zniesienia sankcji. Ponadto \u017c\u0105da, by ten list stwierdza\u0142, \u017ce ka\u017cda deklaracja Zachodu, \u017ce \u201estruktura sankcji pozostaje w mocy\u201d (tj. pozwala na ich natychmiastowe przywr\u00f3cenie) b\u0119dzie uwa\u017cana za \u201eniepodporz\u0105dkowanie si\u0119 JCPOA\u201d przez Zach\u00f3d. Implikacje: <\/I>Te warunki stanowi\u0105 ca\u0142kowit\u0105 zmian\u0119 JCPOA. Chamenei nie pozwala na realizowanie JCPOA przez Iran a\u017c zostanie to zaakceptowane na pi\u015bmie przez drug\u0105 stron\u0119, anuluj\u0105c w ten spos\u00f3b JCPOA uzgodniony 14 lipca 2015 r. Drugi warunek: <\/B>Jakiekolwiek sankcje przeciwko Iranowi, \u201cna ka\u017cdym poziomie i pod ka\u017cdym pretekstem\u201d, w\u0142\u0105cznie z terroryzmem i \u0142amaniem praw cz\u0142owieka, przez jakikolwiek kraj uczestnicz\u0105cy w negocjacjach, b\u0119dzie \u201cstanowi\u0107 pogwa\u0142cenie JCPOA” i pow\u00f3d dla Iranu, by zaprzesta\u0107 realizacji porozumienia\u201d. Implikacje: <\/I>To \u017c\u0105danie, kt\u00f3re wi\u0105\u017ce JCPOA z innymi sprawami i zabrania jakiegokolwiek karania Iranu w jakiejkolwiek sprawie i z jakiegokolwiek powodu, s\u0142u\u017cy jako wym\u00f3wka dla Iranu, by uniewa\u017cni\u0107 porozumienie. Trzeci warunek: <\/B>Zgodnie z JCPOA, Iran jest zobowi\u0105zany po Dniu Przyj\u0119cia JPCOA, wykona\u0107 swoje zobowi\u0105zania dotycz\u0105ce funkcjonowania reaktora j\u0105drowego w Araku i wys\u0142ania wi\u0119kszo\u015bci swoich zapas\u00f3w wzbogaconego uranu. Sprzecznie z tym Chamenei zmienia harmonogram JCPOA, stwierdzaj\u0105c, \u017ce Iran nie wykona tych dzia\u0142a\u0144 zanim Mi\u0119dzynarodowa Agencja Energii Atomowej (MAEA) nie o\u015bwiadczy, \u017ce zamyka dossier o \u201eminionych i przysz\u0142ych kwestiach (w\u0142\u0105cznie z tak zwanymi Mo\u017cliwymi Wymiarami Militarnymi lub PMD) programu nuklearnego Iranu\u201d. Implikacje: <\/I>\u017b\u0105danie zmiany harmonogramu tworzy sytuacj\u0119, w kt\u00f3rej Iran nie podejmie dzia\u0142a\u0144 przewidzianych w JCPOA i nie spe\u0142ni swoich zobowi\u0105za\u0144 zanim nie zostan\u0105 z\u0142agodzone sankcje, tak\u017ce wed\u0142ug JCPOA, ale zamiast tego dyktuje warunek, \u017ce sankcje musz\u0105 najpierw zosta\u0107 zniesione ca\u0142kowicie i stwierdza, \u017ce dopiero wtedy Iran wype\u0142ni swoje zobowi\u0105zania. Chamenei tworzy tutaj sytuacj\u0119, w kt\u00f3rej MAEA nie b\u0119dzie w stanie z\u0142o\u017cy\u0107 raportu o spe\u0142nieniu przez Iran zobowi\u0105za\u0144 dotycz\u0105cych reaktora w Araku i dotycz\u0105cych wys\u0142ania wzbogaconego uranu w ustalonym dniu 15 grudnia 2015 r., poniewa\u017c Iran nie zrobi tego w przewidzianym czasie – i w ten spos\u00f3b realizacja porozumienia zostaje udaremniona od samego pocz\u0105tku. Czwarty warunek: <\/B>Iran spe\u0142ni swoje zobowi\u0105zania do „renowacji” i zmiany celu reaktora w Araku, dopiero kiedy b\u0119dzie podpisane porozumienie o \u201cplanie alternatywnym\u201d dla zmian w reaktorze i po tym, jak otrzyma \u201cwystarczaj\u0105c\u0105 gwarancj\u0119\u201d, \u017ce ten plan alternatywny zostanie zrealizowany. Implikacje: <\/I>Spe\u0142nienie przez Iran zobowi\u0105za\u0144 w sprawie reaktora w Araku, okre\u015blonych przez JCPOA, zostanie odroczone do nieznanej daty w przysz\u0142o\u015bci. Pi\u0105ty warunek: <\/B>Iran wykona zobowi\u0105zanie wys\u0142ania swojego wzbogaconego uranu do innego kraju w zamian za yellowcake<\/I> „stopniowo i przy wielu okazjach\u201d i dopiero po tym, jak \u201czabezpieczone porozumienie zosta\u0142o w tej sprawie sfinalizowane, wraz z wystarczaj\u0105cymi gwarancjami\u201d, \u017ce tak wymiana b\u0119dzie dokonana. Implikacje: <\/I>Data, w kt\u00f3rej Iran mia\u0142 wys\u0142a\u0107 za granice wzbogacony uran, ustalona w JCPOA, zostaje odsuni\u0119ta w jak\u0105\u015b nieznan\u0105 przysz\u0142o\u015b\u0107. Chamenei \u017c\u0105da, by Iran otrzyma\u0142 w zamian za wzbogacony uran nie surowy uran, jak to okre\u015bla JCPOA, ale uran wzbogacony, cho\u0107 do ni\u017cszego poziomu ni\u017c uran wys\u0142any. Jest to jeszcze jedna zmiana JCPOA, tak jak zosta\u0142o uzgodnione 14 lipca 2015 r. Sz\u00f3sty warunek: <\/B>Chamenei nakazuje prezydentowi Rohaniemu, by wraz z redukowaniem zdolno\u015bci Iranu do wzbogacania uranu, zgodnie z JCPOA, natychmiast rozpocz\u0105\u0142 rozszerza\u0107 zdolno\u015b\u0107 Iranu do wzbogacania uranu z 15-letnim, d\u0142ugoterminowym planem doj\u015bcia do liczby 190 tysi\u0119cy centryfug SWU (Separative Work Units). M\u00f3wi: „Ten plan musi rozwia\u0107 wszystkie niepokoje, wynikaj\u0105ce z niekt\u00f3rych punkt\u00f3w zawartych w aneksach JCPOA\u201d. Implikacje: <\/I>Ten artyku\u0142 anuluje deklarowany cel JCPOA, kt\u00f3rym jest zredukowania mo\u017cliwo\u015bci wzbogacania uranu przez Iran. Si\u00f3dmy warunek: <\/B>Ira\u0144ska Organizacja Energii Atomowej musi zapewni\u0107 kontynuacj\u0119 bada\u0144 i rozwoju w dziedzinie j\u0105drowej w jej rozmaitych aspektach, tak \u017ce za osiem lat Iranowi nie zabraknie technologii wzbogacania. To wszystko, powiada, jest zgodne z JCPOA. \u00d3smy warunek: <\/B>W wypadku w\u0105tpliwo\u015bci lub niejednoznaczno\u015bci w sprawie tekstu JCPOA, \u017ar\u00f3d\u0142em usuwaj\u0105cym t\u0119 w\u0105tpliwo\u015b\u0107 lub niejednoznaczno\u015b\u0107 b\u0119dzie tre\u015b\u0107 rozm\u00f3w – tj. b\u0119dzie tak\u017ce zawiera\u0142o wypowiedzi strony ira\u0144skiej, nie za\u015b tylko \u201cinterpretacj\u0119 dostarczon\u0105 przez stron\u0119 przeciwn\u0105\u201d, to jest, P5+1. Implikacje: <\/I>Ka\u017cda w\u0105tpliwo\u015b\u0107 lub niejednoznaczno\u015b\u0107 dotycz\u0105ca tre\u015bci JCPOA stanie si\u0119 \u017ar\u00f3d\u0142em nieko\u0144cz\u0105cego si\u0119 sporu i sparali\u017cuje wszelk\u0105 mo\u017cliwo\u015b\u0107 zrealizowania porozumienia. Dziewi\u0105ty warunek: <\/B>Z powodu obaw, \u017ce druga strona, szczeg\u00f3lnie USA, z\u0142amie obietnice lub b\u0119dzie oszukiwa\u0107, prezydent Rohani musi stworzy\u0107 \u201cdobrze poinformowany i bystry panel\u201d do monitorowania realizacji porozumienia. Implikacje: <\/I>Chamenei tworzy ramy administracyjne dla wiecznych op\u00f3\u017anie\u0144 realizacji porozumienia. Chamenei doda\u0142 tak\u017ce 10. warunek<\/B>, skierowany do Iranu, nie do P5+1, \u017c\u0105daj\u0105c, by Rohani powa\u017cnie potraktowa\u0142 jego instrukcje w kwestii \u201cgospodarki oporu\u201d, kt\u00f3rej g\u0142\u00f3wnym motywem jest samowystarczalno\u015b\u0107, zamiast opierania gospodarki Iranu na \u017ar\u00f3d\u0142ach zewn\u0119trznych. \u017b\u0105da tak\u017ce, by po zniesieniu sankcji nie by\u0142o \u017cadnego \u201cniepohamowanego importu\u201d i w og\u00f3le \u017cadnego importu z USA. Polityczne konsekwencje w Iranie<\/B> W lutym 2016 r. w Iranie maj\u0105 odby\u0107 si\u0119 wybory do Mad\u017clisu i do Zgromadzenia Ekspert\u00f3w. Ob\u00f3z pragmatyczny, na kt\u00f3rego czele stoj\u0105 Haszemi Rafsand\u017cani i prezydent Rohani, mieli nadziej\u0119, \u017ce szybka realizacja porozumienia pozwoli na z\u0142agodzenie sankcji i natychmiastowe uwolnienie funduszy, co z kolei pozwoli obozowi pragmatycznemu na przedstawienie tych osi\u0105gni\u0119\u0107 i triumfu w wyborach. Jednak przez ustanowienie tych warunk\u00f3w Chamenei udaremni\u0142 szybk\u0105 realizacj\u0119 porozumienia i w ten spos\u00f3b udaremni\u0142 nadzieje obozu pragmatycznego na sukces wyborczy. [Poni\u017cej – bez przek\u0142adu na polski – znajduje si\u0119 pe\u0142na wersja listu Chameneiego oraz Aneksy zawieraj\u0105ce tweety Chameneiego i inne dokumenty<\/I>] IRIB Translation <\/B> The following is the official English translation of Khamenei’s letter, as published by IRIB.<\/A> [2]<\/A> This translation was tweeted by Khamenei and also posted on his Facebook page (see Appendix I and II<\/B>). „Wednesday, 21 October 2015 17:41 „Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei, the Leader of the Islamic Revolution, in a letter to President Hassan Rouhani, who also heads the Supreme National Security Council (SNSC), referred to the precise and responsible examination of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) in the Islamic Consultative Assembly (parliament) and also the SNSC, and the clearance of this agreement through legal channels, and issued important instructions regarding the observation of and safeguarding the country\u2019s national interests. Enumerating nine-point requirements for the implementation of the JCPOA, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei endorsed SNSC Resolution 634, dated August 10, 2015, provided that the following provisions and requirements are observed. „The full text of Ayatollah Khamenei\u2019s letter follows on: „In the Name of Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful<\/B> „Your Excellency, Mr Rouhani, „The agreement known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) has already been cleared through legal channels following precise and responsible examinations in the Islamic Consultative Assembly, [parliamentary] ad hoc committees and other committees as well as the Supreme National Security Council. Since the agreement is waiting for my view, I deem it necessary to remind several points so that Your Excellency and other officials directly or indirectly involved in the issue would have enough time to comply with and safeguard national interests and the country\u2019s best interests. „1. Before anything else, I deem it necessary to extend my gratitude to all those involved in this challenging procedure throughout all its periods, including the recent nuclear negotiating team whose members tried their best in explaining the positive points and incorporating all those points [into the agreement], critics who reminded all of us of weak points through their appreciable meticulousness, and particularly the chairman and members of the Majlis ad hoc committee [set up to review the JCPOA] as well as the senior members of the SNSC who covered some voids by including their important considerations, and finally the Speaker of Majlis and Members of Parliament who adopted a cautious bill to show the right way of implementation [of the agreement] to the administration, and also national media and the country\u2019s journalists who despite all their differences of view presented a complete image of this agreement to public opinion. This voluminous collection of activity and endeavors and thoughts [spent] on an issue which is thought to be among the unforgettable and instructive issues of the Islamic Republic, deserves appreciation and is a source of satisfaction. Therefore, one can say with certainty that the divine reward for these responsible contributions will, God willing, include assistance and mercy and guidance by Almighty God because the divine promises of assistance in exchange for assisting His religion are unbreakable. „2. Enjoying decades-long background of presence in the very details of the affairs of the Islamic Republic of Iran, you must have naturally realized that the government of the United States of America, neither in the nuclear issue nor in any other issue, had been pursuing no other approach but hostility and disturbance, and is unlikely to do otherwise in the future either. The remarks by the US President [Barack Obama] in two letters addressed to me on the point that [Washington] has no intention of subverting the Islamic Republic of Iran turned out to be unreal and his open threats of military and even nuclear strike, which can result in a lengthy indictment against him in international courts, laid bare the real intentions of US leaders. Political pundits and public opinion of many nations clearly understand that the case of his never-ending hostility is the nature and identity of the Islamic Republic of Iran, which is born out of the Islamic Revolution. Insistence on rightful Islamic stances and opposition to the hegemonic and arrogant system, perseverance against excessive demands and encroachment upon oppressed nations, revelations on the US support for medieval dictators and suppression of independent nations, incessant defense for the Palestinian nation and patriotic resistance groups, rational and globally popular yelling at the usurping Zionist regime constitute the main items which make the US regime\u2019s enmity against the Islamic Republic inevitable, and this enmity will continue as long as the Islamic Republic [continues to] disappoint them with its internal and sustainable strength. „The behavior and words of the US government in the nuclear issue and its prolonged and boring negotiations showed that this (nuclear issue) was also another link in their chain of hostile enmity with the Islamic Republic. Their deception through flip-flopping between their initial remarks that came after Iran accepted to hold direct talks with them and their constant non-compliance with their pledges throughout two-year-long negotiations and their alignment with the demands of the Zionist regime and their bullying diplomacy regarding relations with European governments and bodies involved in the negotiations are all indicative of the fact that the US\u2019s deceitful involvement in the nuclear negotiations has been done not with the intention of a fair settlement [of the case], but with the ill intention of pushing ahead with its hostile objectives about the Islamic Republic. „Doubtlessly, vigilance vis-\u00e0-vis the hostile intentions of the US government and instances of resistance on the part of the officials of the Islamic Republic of Iran throughout the negotiations managed, in numerous cases, to prevent heavy damage from being inflicted [upon Iran]. „However, the outcome of the negotiations, which is enshrined in the JCPOA, has numerous ambiguities and structural weaknesses that could inflict big damage on the present and the future of the country in the absence of meticulous and constant monitoring. „3. The nine-point provisions entailed in the recent bill adopted by the Majlis and the 10-point instructions outlined in the resolution of the Supreme National Security Council carry helpful and effective points which must be taken into consideration. Meantime, there are some other necessary points which are announced here while some of the points mentioned in the two documents are highlighted. „First, since Iran has accepted to negotiate basically for the objective of removal of unjust economic and financial sanctions and its enforcement (the lifting of sanctions) is tied to Iran\u2019s future actions under the JCPOA, it is necessary that solid and sufficient guarantees be arranged to avoid any infraction by the opposite parties. Written declaration by the US president and the European Union for the lifting of the sanctions is among them. In the statements of the EU and the US president, it must be reiterated that these sanctions will be fully lifted. Any declaration that the structure of the sanctions will remain in force shall imply non-compliance with the JCPOA. „Second, throughout the eight-year period, any imposition of sanctions at any level and under any pretext (including repetitive and fabricated pretexts of terrorism and human rights) on the part of any of the countries involved in the negotiations will constitute a violation of the JCPOA and the [Iranian] government would be obligated to take the necessary action as per Clause 3 of the Majlis bill and stop its activities committed under the JCPOA. „Third, the measures related to what is mentioned in the next two clauses will start only after the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) announces [the conclusion of] the past and future issues (including the so-called Possible Military Dimensions or PMD of Iran\u2019s nuclear program). „Fourth, measures to renovate the Arak plant by preserving its heavy [water] nature will start only after a firm and secure agreement has been signed on an alternative plan, along with sufficient guarantees for its implementation. „Fifth, the deal with a foreign government for swapping enriched uranium with yellow cake will start only after a secure agreement has been clinched to that effect, along with sufficient guarantees [for its implementation]. The aforesaid deal and exchange must be done on a gradual basis and on numerous occasions. „Sixth, by virtue of the Majlis bill, the plan and the necessary preparations for mid-term development of the atomic energy industry, which includes the method of advancement in different periods of time for 15 years for the final objective of 190,000 SWU, must be drawn up and carefully reviewed by the Supreme National Security Council. This plan must allay any concern stemming from some points entailed in the JCPOA appendices. „Seventh, the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran must organize research and development in different aspects such that after the end of the eight-year period, there would be no shortage of technology for the level of [uranium] enrichment entailed in the JCPOA. „Eighth, it must be noted that on the ambiguous points in the JCPOA document, the interpretation provided by the opposite party is not acceptable and the reference would be the text of the negotiations. „Ninth, the existence of complications and ambiguities in the text of the JCPOA and the suspicion of breach of promise, infractions and deception by the opposite party, particularly the US, require that a well-informed and smart panel be established to monitor the progress of affairs and [gauge] the opposite party\u2019s commitment and realization of what was mentioned above. The composition and the tasks of this would-be panel should be determined and approved by the Supreme National Security Council. „In witness whereof, Resolution 634, dated August 10, 2015, of the Supreme National Security Council, is endorsed pending the observation of the aforementioned points. „In conclusion, as it has been notified in numerous meetings to you and other government officials and also to our dear people in public gatherings, although the lifting of sanctions is a necessary job in order to remove injustice [imposed on people] and regain the rights of the Iranian nation, economic overture and better livelihood and surmounting the current challenges will not be easy unless the Economy of Resistance is taken seriously and followed up on entirely. It is hoped that this objective will be pursued with full seriousness and special attention would be paid to enhancing national production. You should also watch out so that unbridled imports would not follow the lifting of sanctions, and particularly importing any consumer materials from the US must be seriously avoided. „I pray to Almighty God for your and other contributors\u2019 success. *Y. Carmon jest prezesem MEMRI; A. Savyon jest dyrektork\u0105 MEMRI Iran Project. <\/I> Appendix I: Khamenei’s Letter On Twitter<\/B><\/A> [3]<\/B><\/A> Appendix II: Khamenei’s Letter On Facebook<\/B><\/A> [4]<\/B><\/A> Endnotes: <\/A> [1]<\/A> See: MEMRI TV Clip No. 5114, Iranian Guardian Council Secretary-General Ahmad Jannati: Khamenei Has Not Approved or Signed the JCPOA,<\/A> October 16, 2015; MEMRI TV Clip No. 5117, Iranian Guardian Council Spokesman Nejatollah Ebrahimian: The JCPOA Was Not Approved by the Majlis or the Guardian Council<\/A>, October 18, 2015; MEMRI Inquiry & Analysis No.1192, The Iranian Majlis Has Not Approved The JCPOA But Iran’s Amended Version Of It<\/A>, October 13, 2015; MEMRI Special Dispatch No. 6191, Iranian Supreme Leader Khamenei, Iranian Officials Speak Out Against Iranian Approval Of JCPOA<\/A> October 18, 2015. Visit the MEMRI site in Polish: <\/B>http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polish\/<\/A>
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25367.jpg\")
\n
\n„Ayatollah Khamenei sends a letter to President Hassan Rouhani about the JCPOA
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n„President of the Islamic Republic of Iran and Head of the Supreme National Security Council
\n„May God bestow success upon you.
\n„Greetings to You
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n
\n„Source: www. leader. ir”
\n
\n
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25369.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25370.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25371.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25372.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25373.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25374.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25375.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25376.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25377.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25378.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25379.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25380.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25381.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25382.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25383.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25384.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25385.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25386.jpg\")
\n
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25387.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25388.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25389.jpg\")
\n![](\"http:\/\/www2.memri.org\/polaco\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/12\/25390.jpg\")
\n
\n
\n<\/A> [2]<\/A> English.irib.ir\/news\/leader\/item\/217470-ayatollah-khamenei-sends-a-letter-to-president-hassan-rouhani-about-the-jcpoa, October 21, 2015.
\n<\/A> [3]<\/A> Twitter.com\/khamenei_ir, October 21, 2015.
\n<\/A> [4]<\/A> Facebook.com\/www.Khamenei.ir\/posts\/943612332378368:0, posted October 21, 2015.
\n
\n
\n